Discussion about this post

User's avatar
James M.'s avatar

By our standards (by the goals and values which we prioritize), the "developing" world IS "civilizationally inferior". Human capital, international development, foreign aid - none of these concepts would be necessary if it wasn't.

Yes, language can be a tool of oppression and prejudice (although more often perhaps it's just a reflection of it). But trying to erase any distinction or hierarchy or value judgement in language is an equally political goal, and it can be equally false. Westerners often like to pretend that there's a kind of innate worthiness to ALL cultures. Of course, this conceit falls apart as soon as they begin talking about ACTUAL foreign cultures, or history... or when they must choose a place to live.

By the standards of the modern world, the developed world is a safer, richer, easier, more opportunity-laden setting in which to build a life. It is better, and the developing world is worse. I'm not defending the term "third world" but it shouldn't be abandoned simply because it generalizes or stigmatizes or makes value judgements. Value judgements are necessary and unavoidable. Some things (cultures, beliefs, people) are simply better than others.

https://jmpolemic.substack.com/p/white-supremacy

Expand full comment
carlos riveros's avatar

So you espouse speech fascism and silencing the Truth, no matter how painful- triggering delusion & zero improvement where non-performers never improve without the needed criticism and peer pressure. This actually is evil- keeps mediocre countries mediocre. Be proud of your culture even though it sux. Be proud even when most of your country yearns to emigrate. Encourage host countries to virtue-signal accommodate immigrants by adopting the customs of inferior cultures, instead of mandating them to assimilate & adopt the better habits that contributed to making the host nation a world leader and immigration magnet.

Bravo. Make all cultures equally mediocre / discourage individual progress.

Expand full comment
23 more comments...

No posts